Sensemakinng: Understanding the Controlling Narratives and the Weaponization of Language in 2020 

Estimated 4 minutes read: Controlling the Narratives and the Weaponization of Language in 2020 

It doesn’t take a behavioural linguistic analysis of government's narratives and the systems of control of information around Covid-19 to see what is going on. 

Even using the words/labels “Covid-19” or “CoronaVirus” could, and probably will get this article flagged and suppressed when posted on social media and in search engine rankings. Such is the monitoring of information, the suppression of debate and the control of the narrative. 

The language patterns of the UK government and other governments around the world around this pandemic are very telling. Telling in both what it is and is not saying. 

Two statements we heard around the world at the start of this pandemic were “flu-like symptoms” and that those people who had died from it had “underlying health conditions.” 

Both statements had since been proven to be only partly true at best. Now the rational mind might excuse this and say, ‘yes but that is because there was not a lot known about the disease at the start.” And yes that, to an extent is true, apart from the fact that doctors in Wuhan were describing it more like pneumonia than flu right from the start. And many people, of all ages, were dying that had no underlying health conditions, or mild conditions at best. 

It is more likely that these two statements are designed to instil a level of calm in the global communities and to avoid panic. But of course, what they have added to is the public becoming warier and less trusting of official government sources and international organisations. The UK government has even slipped up on a few occasions on their daily briefing by saying when grilled by the press, that they only made those, or similar statements so as not to cause a national panic. Of course, this triggers in the back of anyone's mind, that is paying attention, ‘what else are they not telling us, or are lying to us about?’ 

Further to this, the language being used has been combative. Describing it as “a fight”, “a war” and health workers as being “on the front line.” This is worrying for so many reasons but mainly because it weaponizes language and means that people get used to it. It is then not too far a stretch for people to start accepting troops on the streets, as we have seen in several instances around the world and forced quarantine, curfews and restrictions on civil rights. For further reading on why this may be an issue see Tim Hawkins 2016 article, which says it all about the weaponization of political language, “Our casual use of military jargon is normalizing the militarization of society.’ 

The weaponization of language also allows room for the erosion of civil rights in order to “protect” a countries citizens. The problem is that the laws that are changed, eroded or replaced during times of conflict have a nasty habit of staying around long after the threat is over.  

These can be infringements of our civil rights, our privacy and even for some their freedom. We saw this in the US and the UK after 9/11 and we see it happening today. These erosions can affect our privacy in the name of protection by allowing intelligence services, and other parties, the right of surveillance of their own countries citizens, their movements, what groups they belong to, what they are saying and even, with bio-surveillance, of their health.  

In the height of the Covid-19 pandemic, we have seen the use of this language of “fighting the invisible enemy” to justify the lockdown of free movement (showing how free we truly are as citizens of the world), the police with new enforcement laws and the introduction of apps for tracking and tracing people, without any explanation of the impact of privacy.  

The new era of facial recognition and health monitoring brings with it the potential of biopsychical and even emotional surveillance. This can be done by monitoring things like body temperature and heart rate. If this is then cross-referenced with location date, which it will be, it could be determined to establish your emotional reaction to a political speech, your reactions to news and your level of agreement, and even level of taking part in, acts of civil disobedience and protest. Sound farfetched? The technology already exists and is in use in places like China and certain parts of the Middle East.  

Maybe you don’t believe this could be ever used in the western world. That democracy would stop it. Well so far, as the instances of rights removed during 9/11 show, the west does not have a history of backing up the theory. Yes, there may be more control, or just more secrecy around its use (as we saw with the Snowden leaks), but even if you believe that the current democratic setups would stop this what happens when someone gets into power with the intention of using the technology to bring about a police state.  

The weaponization of language to normalise military action and erosion of civil rights in or to ‘protect’ a countries citizen is nothing new. But when you add in the restrictions of movement and now the race riots and protests in the US it can start to feel like the world is on the brink of a new norm, and one that is not a positive change for the better. 

Even if you dismiss the threat of surveillance technology, monitoring the language used, the repetitiveness of its nature and filtering it through our own behavioural linguistic analysis, metacognitive processes and critical thinking ability will help with both our sensemaking ability but also the level to which we ‘buy-in’ to the narrative. I am not saying we go all conspiracy theory on it, but we would be foolish if we didn’t think that there may be additional motives and agendas behind the language used.  

Most countries are having daily briefing from their government. But these have become not just daily updates on the spread and suppression of the virus but also political campaign platforms. We see this in the US and the UK. In the US we see it blatantly with Trump’s usual blunt, aggressive and unapologetic style. Even to the point of him running a campaign-style video during one of his press conferences. In the UK it has been somewhat more subtle, depending on which secretary of state is taking the lead that day, but it has been a constant advertorial of boasting and self-congratulation for the Conservative party.  

What could be the problem here? Well if you stay glued to the daily briefings, as many of us did at the start, you can find yourself internalising the constant repetitive narratives and starting to not only believe them but feel emotionally connected to them. This is exactly the desired effect. Why is this a problem when they are telling us to “save lives” and “protect the NHS?” Well, those two phrases and mantras may be harmless enough. But behind those statements are more subtle messages that allow and excuse the constant erosion of civil liberties and freedoms.  

You can also almost feel yourself feel sorry for the Prime Minister and start having the feeling that ‘he is alright actually’ and ‘I liked him when he was on Have I Got News For You’ he can’t be all bad. You can find yourself buying into the bumbling Etonian English gent routine and forgetting all the horrible racist, misogynistic and hurtful things he has said. The lies he has told and the Conservative agenda to self-off the NHS by stealth.  

The language we use is important. Words have power. The words of those in power is even more important to break down and understand. We, as humans, make sense of the world through language, we think mainly in words and those words swim around in our psyche affecting our thoughts and feelings. These feelings cause emotions and emotions cause neurological chemical reactions which affect our biological and psychological wellbeing.  

By developing our metacognitive and critical thinking abilities we can protect ourselves from these influences whilst still taking in the latest data and scientific findings. Only by doing this can we make sense of what is really going on and gain a level of peace needed in these difficult times.  

 

--- 

The following article will look at censorship of alternative narratives in times of pandemic or war.  

This article was written by Sam our Founder, Editor and Chief Behavioural Anarchist. Sam is a Data-Driven Marketing and Behavioural Communication’s Strategist based in Telford, Shropshire in the UK.

Here he is a Writer on Behavioural Insights, Media, Communications, Data Science & Marketing Technology. Keeping a watchful eye and investigating the misuse of technology and behavioural science by big business, media, and politicians in manipulating online narratives to sway public opinion. All opinions are his own. :

All images on this site used under CC0 License
✓ Free for personal and commercial use
✓ No attribution required, however, we try to contribute to the artist if known.

Join our social community today! Be part of the conversation.

We have a wealth of digital, direct and data-driven marketing content for people looking to shape change by setting up their own business, social enterprise or cause. Membership is free and all we ask in turn is that you be part of the conversation with an aim to shaping positive change in the world. 

The term social marketing often gets confused with social media marketing. To make matters worse social marketing quite often uses social media in its marketing toolkit. But social marketing is actually a discipline in and of itself. It is used to influence positive behavioural changes in society, communities and organisations.  

Social marketers have to have a keen understanding of not just marketing and communications…

Read more…

Individuality

We are all different and because of that, we all see the world in our own unique way as we delete, distort and generalise what we take in based on our cognitive biases. Yet in many ways we are predictable and because of this we can break down people and groups of people into types. This can be very useful when we are looking to market or communicate an idea or we are looking to bring about change.

There are many psychometric, biopsychosocial,…

Read more…

A useful toolbox for consumer profiling, behavioural marketing and communications analysis, strategic SEO and digital marketing planning but also a great set of tools, techniques and technologies for combating online threats, fraud and bullying.

Forensic Behavioural Linguistics in Digital Marketing

At iLife, we conduct forensic behavioural linguistics and psychometric profiling to gain insight into customers personas, their online behaviour, their likes and…

Read more…

Behavioural Economics

Let's start with this article by introducing you to the world of behavioural economics. What is it? It is literally as it sounds. Its where the behavioural sciences meet the world of economics. It’s the field of study in psychology that looks at how or why we make economic decisions. Yes, it’s a thing, and it’s a serious area of academic research. It is also something that many advertisers and marketers are turning in order to influence us more effectively. Not to mention political parties…

Read more…

Bombarded by words

We spend our days being bombarded by words. From the first thoughts that jump into our heads as we wake up to the very last thoughts that fill our minds as we try to fall asleep.  

Some of these we notice, some we do not.  

We have words thrown at us from every direction. Infiltrating our very thoughts.  

Whether we throw on the TV, switch on the radio or just look at our smartphones first thing we start our days with the words of others entering into our reality. If we…

Read more…

Our words matter.

In fact, they are paramount.

The words we choose to speak, listen to and tell ourselves shape the narratives of our lives and the lives around us. Words and the narratives they form shape society and indeed the world.

Through your words, I have a window into your world and far too often your words betray your inner secrets.

I can use your words to market to you. To sell you an idea and to get inside your mind.

Words and cutlery separate us…

Read more…

Have you ever noticed how everybody in a conversation seems to be poised to talk and say their piece and no one ever seems to be really listening. This is something I have found fascinating since a small child. I was very shy as a child and often in a room full of adults talking about something that I was either too young to understand or was not really meant…

Read more…

Lesson 10: Pull the buying trance trigger

By this point you have read 9 powerful sales and communications lessons that all on their own can get you to this point. All, have their own powers on a conscious and subconscious level but when they are all combined, subtly, or a mix of them are brought together they become some of the most powerful persuasion techniques in the world to influence the thinking and the mind of…

Read more…