Politics

Online Harms White Paper - Government Consultation - My response

I recently joined the Open Rights Group as a member and was asked to respond to the Governments Online Harms regulation plans within their open consultation which ends the 1st of July - Online Harms White Paper - Government Consultation 

Below is my response. Please do the same and keep the UK free from unelected regulators that could harm freeness of speech. 

While we all agree there is a need to tackle and deal with both illegal and harmful content online this must be put into the balance with our basic human rights of freedom of expression. 

Users of social media, blogging sites and sites that encourage this freedom of expression need to be able to defend their right to publish legal content. 

This issue with a regulatory framework, like the one you are suggesting, is that online companies will take the easy route to compliance. This is that they will create automated, indiscriminate algorithms and technology that just takes down content that 'might' fall under the online harms act. 

Whilst this might be fine for the clearly illegal content its the content that sits in the grey box of not being illegal but may cause harm. There is too much ambiguity here and with that, there is room for massive error and the closing down of legitimate content. 

Digital companies will take the easy route out as we see YouTube and others doing now when it comes to claims of Copyright. They do not contact the person being claimed against, they do not check the validity of the claim, they just delete the content, or de-monetise or de-platform the user. 

This can become a form of censorship that could mean individual users could get de-platformed for their point of view.  

Let's just look at the term 'disinformation' who defines what this is, is there a clear definition and who decides that boundary. We could say political propaganda and the PR business around it is 'disinformation'.

We also have to ask the question where is the task force to tackle those perpetrating the  'illegal harms'. 

This legislation seems tailored to tackling the platforms and the removal of content. But where are the plans to tackle those that are clearly committing illegal acts of harm?

My fear is also for those who unwittingly promote or forward on 'disinformation' as you will see if you read the demos report "Warring Songs: Information Operations in the Digital Age" shows how a)Fact checking alone is not enough as it only deals with a small % of the issue and b)people can unwittingly be drawn into promoting content from these Information Operations. These people could be de-platformed, silenced or censored which is an infringement of their human rights.

A quote from the Newstatesmen summaries it well "Disinformation is particularly blurry, and will likely prove contentious for a future regulator. The DCMS spells out some expectations, including “promoting authoritative news sources”, and suppressing content “disputed by reputable fact-checking services”.

How far should the government go in determining what fictions are acceptable? When does a legitimate hunch become a conspiracy theory? These are political questions that require considered – and democratic – responses. While the government’s move towards regulating the internet is a welcome step, there will be many who look at these proposals with justified suspicion."

The scheme pushes towards automated takedowns and speed, both of which are likely to come at the cost of accuracy. Accuracy is as important as removal for a scheme to be legitimate.

This process of using an Independent Regulator is also very questionable. They will not be elected but will have great power to decide what is free expressions it protects and what it restricts. This does not promote fair and accurate decisions. 

The UK does not, and should not, allow state regulation of the press, allowing them to freely challenge and comment on issues, why would we not allow the same freedoms to millions of citizens and their lawful online speech. 

Read more about Open Rights Group’s position here:
https://www.openrightsgroup.org/about/reports/org-policy-responses-to-online-harms-white-paper

View the full DCMS consultation:
https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/online-harms-white-paper

 

There is also no explanation as to how harms and risk are being defined which is a central question of the duty of care. This could be too wide and impact legitimate online speech.

The proposal is also unrealistically vast and broad which will make them almost impossible to implement without a scatter gun approach that forces companies to take down legitimate content with no route to complain by the user. A more focused rights-based approach on social media as promoted by the Open Rights Group makes more sense. 

Before going ahead with such a scheme there needs to be more public and industry consultation in order to facilitate discussions on a better way forward. 

This article was written by Sam our Founder, Editor and Chief Behavioural Marketing Anarchist. Sam is an SEO Analyst & Data-Driven Marketing Strategist based in Telford, Shropshire in the UK.

Here he is a Writer on Behavioural Insights, Media, Communications, Data Science & Marketing Technology. Keeping a watchful eye and investigating the misuse of technology and behavioural science by big business, media, and politicians in manipulating online narratives to sway public opinion. All opinions are his own. :

All images on this site used under CC0 License
✓ Free for personal and commercial use
✓ No attribution required, however, we try to contribute to the artist if known.

Join our social community today! Be part of the conversation.

We have a wealth of digital, direct and data-driven marketing content for people looking to shape change by setting up their own business, social enterprise or cause. Membership is free and all we ask in turn is that you be part of the conversation with an aim to shaping positive change in the world. 

Sam posted a video
This shit is nuts, feels so right and the dawn of something amazing. I just bought his Book on Audible
We have no clue how consciousness emerges from 3 pounds of wet goo. Cognitive scientist Don Hoffman takes us deep into his research suggesting we…
Nov 27
Sam published an article
The initial onslaught of hype, panic and surge in consultants offering advice on GDPR up to its official launch in May 2018 certainly made it feel, to marketers at least, like a massive constraint in marketing. We had just gotten used to phrases suc…
Nov 24
Sam and Adude Fafe Akue are now friends
Nov 20
Adude Fafe Akue updated their profile
Nov 20
Sam posted a video
Deepfakes: this deep fake video wants to warn you about deep fakes. With a general election just around the corner, it is crucial that people not only recognise how easy it is to be fooled by this kind of technology but also need to be reminded to c…
Nov 19
Adude Fafe Akue and NewHumanNewEarth joined Sleepless Dystopian
Nov 19
Sam published an article
It is polling time again soon in the UK and who are you going to vote for? Do you know? Have you made up your mind? Or are you going to listen to what's said and make and “informed decision?” 
Is that even possible in today’s world? Can you make sen…
Nov 18
Sam published articles
Sep 24
Sam posted videos
Sep 19
Editorial Team published an article
Are you a chess player that wants to take it to the next level? Think you're a chessmaster? Now you can find out with free downloads online.
There are several websites that offer free downloads. Some of the websites are www.playfirst.com, directgame…
Sep 14
Sam published an article
Our words matter.
In fact, they are paramount.
The words we choose to speak, listen to and tell ourselves shape the narratives of our lives and the lives around us. Words and the narratives they form shape society and indeed the world.
Through your…
Sep 10
Editorial Team published an article
What is a Great Free Online Data Storage Site for Home Use?
In light of the recent increase in data storage for business consumers, there are also quite a few free online data storage sites opening up for the average computer user who needs to make…
Sep 7
Editorial Team published an article
Now that you are making your own homemade beer, you should begin to look for beer clubs in your area. Maybe even start your own.
Networking is the key to success in any venture and beer clubs are a great way to get together with fellow homebrewers.…
Sep 1
Sam posted a blog post
I have so much to say right now with everything going on in the world and the disinformation and cognitive propaganda machines in full swing. 
Unfortunately between working around 60 hours a week, studying for my postgrad in data-driven marketing an…
Aug 29
Sam posted a video
What can we trust? Why is the 'information ecology' so damaged, and what would it take to make it healthy? This is a fundamental question, because without good sensemaking, we cannot even begin to act in the world.
It is also a central concern in wh…
Aug 29
Sam published an article
More and more people are trying to lose weight the natural way. This often means by controlling their diet and following a good exercise program. But along with these weight loss ideas many people are desperately looking for other answer to speed up…
Aug 25
More…